Thoughts on bagpiping in the San Francisco Bay Area. For more information, contact PiperJohnB.com
Showing posts with label bay area bagpiper. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bay area bagpiper. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 24, 2016

On recording piping as a practice tool

In preparing to record a quick march medley as a try-out to join our competition band, I have begun to record my playing on a regular basis. When reviewing the first recordings I was struck at how hard it is to get a solid performance worthy of being listened to. Ok, in our heads as humans, we think we sound so much better than what others may say or feel. Ask the person who sings in their shower how they sound, or ask the piper how they think they sound. We each have an inner voice that thinks, ”Hmm, I sound pretty good…” Yet, record the amateur singer, or piper, and make it available for critique and you have another matter. The first few recordings made will ‘feel’ dreadful as pipers are not used to listening to themselves, and while listening, every little flaw seems magnified. Persevere and soon the novelty wears off and the recordings become another tool to help make oneself a better piper. You are playing for yourself, so make the most of it.

So how do you record bagpiping? This is not to record for a future hit CD, but for recording technique and correcting mistakes heard. If you’ve taken lessons, one of the benefits is the feedback from your tutor. The same holds with recording. Do I use an iPhone or smartphone app? Portable camera? Laptop with sound recording program? Cassette recorder? Each has value. I started with my smart phone to record. Then tried a small camera that recorded my playing as a video. Then settled on a sound recording app on the laptop. I like the laptop app as it also has the benefit of storing in a format that can be easily saved, shared and / or deleted. If you’re looking for a higher quality bagpipe recording, one software / hardware package for PC or Mac from: http://www.epipes.co.uk/software.html There product looks intriguing, but more than the average piper may wish to invest in as a practice tool.

One of the challenges in recording is the sound volume of bagpipes. This will drive how close you will stand to the recording device. Stand next to the recorder and you will almost certainly have distortion. Stand 6, 8 or maybe 10 feet away and the recording may smooth out. Trial and error will give you an optimum solution. Just to reinforce, these recording are for your private use in order to make your playing better. The recording doesn’t need to be symphonically beautiful.

Next is the location that you will record at or in. Do I record in my living room, my garage, an empty work conference room, a public park or in a large performance venue? Will the location have echo or other sounds that may be introduced into your recording? For example, last week it rained near my work. I went out at lunch between raindrops to practice and record, to an open parking lot. I recorded several versions of tunes and went back to work. That evening I listened to the efforts only to discover that a frog, or frogs, had joined me, singing their happy ‘rib bits’ to my version of Meeting of the Waters. Too funny! I never heard them while I played. Another factor outside may be wind. You may hear the wind on the recording as it passes across the microphone. The type of mic used may also contribute to hearing the wind. The wind may also carry your music away causing a ‘warped’ sounding recording.

The benefits of recording are very direct. Listening to the recording puts you in the seat of a competition judge and quickly pinpoint areas for technique improvement:

* Playing in tune – Upon playback, you will quickly hear if your drones are out of tune with each other. Take time to tune every time you play. Although you may miss a rough tuning of chanter to drones, you will certainly hear any gross out of tuning of chanter, especially top hand ‘F’, ‘G’ and ‘A’
* Fingering technique – Can I hear the ‘G’ on your D-throw; are your doublings even; does your tachums, sound like it is pronounced; are you taorluaths distinct.  
* Blowing evenly – How steady is your pressure being maintained. Blowing verses arm squeeze. Can you hear the steadiness of the music? Are you pressing harder when playing your high hand (high F, G & A) and are they played sharp, indicating overblowing?
* Playing in tempo – You will quickly hear where you rush (or slow down) music phrases.
* Control your instrument
   - Striking In – On a mental roll-off with a one or two beat ‘E’ are you playing with confidence? No early drone or chanter sounds allowed.
   - Cut-offs – Are they clean and controlled, every time?

So to improve for competition, or improve for solo performance, record yourself. When I listen, I have a highlighter pen and music printed off at the ready. Listen the first time with a yellow highlighter, second time with green, 3rd with blue… you get the idea. I’m listening carefully and listening multiple times to a recording, highlighting areas on the music for improvement. Then practice the tune with the marked music until you have fixed the issue. Then the next time you record without sheet music, you’ll hear the difference. It is an iterative and disciplined process.

And it will pay off.  Happy piping!

Friday, July 25, 2014

On Finding Piping Music

PM Willie Lawrie, undated
I stood nervously. “Hi. My name is John and I’m a pipe music junkie”; group response: “Hi John.” With that I opened the 1st meeting of Piping Music Anonymous, Silicon Valley Chapter (PMASV for short). All kidding aside, I have noticed that most pipers love new pipe music. I do. I listen to my fair share of pipe music on-line, on Pandora, on Youtube.com, on iTunes of my own MP3’s and even CD’s in my car. I have more music than I could ever play in books such as Scots Guards Vol. 1 & 2, W. Ross Collection(s), Irish pipe music, Scottish dance tunes, folders and binders of copied music given to me and a fair number of PDF’s. A few weeks ago at pipe band practice I heard a fellow piper playing 'From Maui to Kona' by Bob Worrall. Very catchy tune when played well and at tempo. And I wanted the sheet music; no… I needed the sheet music. So where do you find new music?

In year’s past, I would have fired up my laptop, opened Google.com (or your favorite flavor of search engine) and spent time searching by name (alternate name, composer, composer’s mother’s maiden name, etc.) for a PDF, gif or BMW of the tune. If the tune was a bit obscure, I might get a hit on Bob Dunshire’s forum site finding a discussion that might give me clues on where to find that elusive tune. Occasionally, I’d find a band’s unlocked web site music page with their current play list available in PDF format with my sought after tune included. They don’t call it data (err… tune) mining for nothing. A lot of digging and an occasional gold nugget (of music). I still resort to this process on occasion but with the advent of reliable tune sites, I do it less and less.

Today, I initially visit a couple of sites that publish pipe tunes. My current favorites are:

http://pipetunes.ca/ – Jim McGillivray’s site. One becomes a member, login and buys credits for future tune PDF and mp3 purchases, downloading as you go. Great resource.

http://www.leeandsonsbagpipes.com/ - Jack Lee’s site. Purchase tunes PDF and mp3 as you go with a link to the download emailed to you. Wonderful site.

Coming back to “From Maui to Kona”. My first thought was to go to McGillivray’s site, hoping to download a copy, paying as I go. The composer gets paid a little and the site gets paid a little. And no worries for me about copyright issues. I didn't find the tune there so went to Jack Lee's site where I’ve purchased tunes before as well. Didn't find it there either. I even went online to Ebay.com, then Amazon.com, to see if Worrall’s book was for sale by private party as his book is out of print. No luck there. Like many pipers, we are a determined lot, so I went searching the internet for that elusive PDF. Early one Saturday morning, while the household slept, I made coffee and settled down for a pleasant hour’s search. Going down more than a few rabbit trails, I eventually found a PDF scan of the tune from the original book (I believe). Sorry Bob, I really wanted your book, chuck full of new tunes.

There is also a mountain of public domain tunes. No need to purchase that, right? Technically there is no need to purchase. But the format of the music if you find it may not be neat and clean. Go looking for some of the classic piobaireachd and you may find a copy of a copy of a page typeset and printed in the 1800’s that looks like it was faxed in the early 1900’s. This week, I went looking for classic WWI tune: The Battle of the Somme by William Lawrie and found a copy on pipetunes.ca and a copy as a gif on another site. I decided to spend the few credits with pipetunes.ca and downloaded a beautifully set PDF of the public domain tune as well as an mp3 of the tune to work with. Money well spent.

Starving bagpiper’s aside, paying for tunes is the right thing to do. A composer works hard to create music that is both fun to play and enjoyable to listen to. He (or she) deserves royalties for their intellectual property. It also take guts to publish a book of tunes, yet thankfully some pipers continue to compose. Hardcopy tune books are fun to browse and play through on chanter or even pencil (it just helps to finger a tune as you sight). Maybe soon we will be able to buy a tune book (besides in pdf format) for example College of Piping: Highland Bagpipe Tutor Pioaireached in a form that can be formatted for viewing on and played straight from the iPad or Surface. I think I’ll go in search to see what progressive bagpipe composers are doing.

I might even find a tune I just have to have.

Tuesday, July 8, 2014

Memorial Day (In July?) Semi-Annual Back-to-Basics … Part 3

I remember taking my bagpipes for a spin when I first got them. I took them out of the old wooden case, initially seasoning the leather bag, then put reeds made out of actual reed into the drone stocks, added a chanter reed, inflated the bag, struck in the drones, then chanter and heard a cacophonous sound far out of tune. I was painfully aware that I was doing was probably done in excitement, and ignorance of how to tune. I needed to learn more; I was eager to learn more. That’s how we sometimes learn, by trial and error, learning from our mistakes.

In my Memorial Day Back-to-Basics, Part 1, I talked about the need to strengthen lips, lungs and arm. In Part 2, I spoke to bagpipes basic maintenance. Both parts are about the set-up of the pipes. In part 3, I want to look at tuning. You can have the strength to maintain a steady tone and you can have the lips to play for an hour plus, and your pipes may be set up to play functionally correct, but if your chanter and drones are out of tune, a great performance can turn into a dismal, painful sounding exercise.

Two schools of thought come to mind regarding effective tuning: Tune the tune the drones to the chanter or the chanter to the drones. Won’t they both get your pipes set-up correctly to play? I say yes, but consistent (and correct) technique leads to good piping. There is wisdom in the generations of pipers that came before me. So ask experienced player how they tune and play. Pick their brains. Watch their technique. Try things. Ask more questions, observe how others approach tuning, and playing technique for that matter. Let’s start with tuning the chanter first.

The chanter, made of blackwood or polypenco (a wonderful dense type of plastic), has been designed and refined for a hundred or more years for sound resonance with holes designed for bagpipe fingering. Eight finger holes for creating the scale of notes and two holes at the side of the base of the chanter for sound resonance. Without going into the music scale and it’s fingering, suffice it to say that each of the nine notes on the chanter must be tuned. To tune each note one adds (or subtracts) tape to the top side of the hole open nearest the fingering being played. Many pipers use black electrical tape, others a clear pipe chanter tape. Both work. Both need replacing as they will warn and slip causing a note to go out of tune.

But where to start tuning? Begin by warming up your pipes. Tuning will mean nothing if you start tuning while the pipes are cold. Of course you are developing your ear for tuning correctness. As I warm up, I will adjust my drones and chanter to sound good to myself. Practicing in tune is more fun than playing out of tune. If you are tuned when ‘cold’ as soon as you run through a couple tunes, your chanter and / or drones will be out of tune. Last weekend I played for a wonderful family who held a memorial service for their deceased Dad, sister and friends. I warmed up and tuned in 60 degree F, foggy weather. For the first 15 – 20 minutes of my playing, the weather held, but by thirty minutes into the pre-memorial playing, the sun was out, only wafts of fog remained and I started to go out of tune. If you find yourself in this performance circumstance, between tunes take time to make small adjustments to the drones to match the changing environment. Don’t panic, just take 30 seconds to retune the drones. Then soldier on.

Tuning starts with low ‘A’ on the chanter, the drones shut off. Typically, one changes the depth the chanter reed is seated to tune ‘A’. If you are part of a band, the Pipe Major or Pipe Sergeant will tune to a certain calibration, and let you know. Your job is then to come close to his (or her) tuning before the band tunes for practice. Lately our band has been tuning at 478 – 480 Hz using a tuner. A number of manufacturers have small tuners with digital readouts. My favorite is an iPhone app (not currently available on Androids) called aptly, Bagpipe Tuner from Blair and uses the iPhone mic and has an optional Bluetooth mic to clamp onto chanter or drone. I find that this app works very well. Once ‘A’ is in tune, slowly proceed up the scale adjusting each note, adding or removing tape in very small increments. These notes should be measured against the tuner.

A goal for every piper is, or should be, tuning without the aid of the tuner, tuning by ear. This take practice, and not every piper has the ear to accomplish this. When one plays solo, as long as the chanter and drones is in tune to middle ‘A’ then the performance will sound good. For a band the tuning becomes much more critical. A band is to sound and act as one, playing in unison with both chanters and drones playing the same notes. Extra care need be taken in the upper register of notes as these more easily can shift out of tune. High ‘A’ and middle ‘A’ need to sound essentially the same. One can’t play them simultaneously, but alternating one to the other will help, as long as you blow steadily.

Once the chanter is tuned, play middle ‘A’ on the chanter while the outer drone sounds middle ‘A’. If there is a beating sound, or a sound of ‘wa-wa-wa’ then the two are out of tune. To adjust, sound ‘E’ and reach across with your right hand and adjust the drone in (to shorten / sharpen the tone) or out (to lengthen / flatten the tone) to slow down the beating sound. Note that you can over lengthen or shorten the drone so that there is no beating sound. The drone is in essence on a different note altogether. Sound ‘A’ and repeat until the beating is gone. Here’s another reason to have your pipes properly set-up. Your drone should slide easily, but not too easily. If it’s too tight, you’ll have a hard time sliding the drone; to loose and the drone will move as you play. Next add to play the middle drone and adjust to the outside drone. The chanter can be silent during this, with the chanter eventually being played to hear and adjust the drones to chanter. Finally, stop the middle drone and start the third drone, the low ‘A’. Listen again to the beating adjusting the lower drone slide to match the outside drone tone. Then strike drones and chanter in to sound ‘A’ and listen. It can help to alternate to ‘E’ to listen for dissonance.

Finally, play a tuning scale listening all the while for out of tune notes and drones. If all is good, play a slow air or 2/4 march to hear the tuning. Play something you know by heart (e.g. Green Hills) so you can concentrate on how the pipes sound. Playing something familiar will allow for playing without stress and give your body and ears chance to play ‘normally’. If you are stressed while tuning, your blowing will be higher pressured, your arms and hands tighter and you’ll play elevated and sharp.


So just relax, play tuned, play, then re-tune, and play as if for an audience of only one… yourself.

Monday, June 2, 2014

Memorial Day Semi-Annual Back-to-Basics … Part 2

In part 1 of my Memorial Day Back-to-Basics, I talked about the need to strengthen lips, lungs and arm, in order to play the music we love. With these three working with strength and control, you will be free to relax and play the chanter with more skill. With the big three working together, your mind will be free to concentrate on musical performance. In Part 2, let’s look at the bagpipes themselves.

Maintaining your instrument is fundamental to playing well. Even before playing, you should inspect your instrument, tuning, and warm-up. We sometimes (I know, because I have done it!) jump right into playing our latest and greatest tune without making sure our instrument is ready to be played. This inspection is not necessary every time we pick up our pipes, but certainly before our weekly band practice and any performance. A good rule of thumb is to do the maintenance the evening before an important event.
Start with a quick inspection. Are the drones (both stock end and drone slides), blowpipe and chanter properly hemped? Do the fittings sit too loosely in there stocks. Do the drones’ slides move smoothly but firmly? The last thing you want is to loose the top of a drone when it bumps a door, branch, etc.  Inspecting and adjusting these is to control your instrument to minimize changes in pitch and air loss. If any of these is loose (or too tight), the piper should work with hemp, waxed hemp and Teflon tape to insure the pipes can be adjusted.

You should also check the air tightness of the bag on a quarterly basis. If I’m going through the effort of playing, I sure don’t want to waste any air in keeping my pipes going. Cork the chanter stock (the chanter is removed). Then blow up the bag to the point that the installed drones have all stopped. Set the bag down and listen as the air slowly escapes. Listen and time on a watch for which drone plays first, which is second and third.  The drones should all hold and then moan at about the same time, in thirty to 40 seconds. If they don’t, then there may be a need to adjust the drone reed and / or drone valve (if you use valves). Also listen to the blow pipe for any air exiting due to the flapper valve not seating properly. Fix or replace as needed.
Then look at the pipe chanter for any tuning tape applied. Review that the tape is new and not slipping from the hole it is tuning. If it’s slipping or sticky when removed and re-applied, then it is time to replace the tape. Some pipers use black electrical tape, others use a clear bagpipe tape. As the weather changes, so does our tuning. So always have a piece (or two) of fresh unused tape stuck to your chanter sole in case you need to replace a piece.

Do you use a moisture system with your pipes? Moisture is one of the enemies of our pipes staying in tune. I highly encourage the use of moisture control systems. I use one moisture trap attached to my blow pipe and then secondary moisture capture to each drone. There are many different ways to capture the moisture in our breath. Some people swear by one brand over another. The key is to be using one. To use one, also means to maintain them. So I use a pipe bag with a zipper that lets me access the bag and moisture systems. I will regularly clean and dry the moisture systems. Another time we can speak to the different types on the market.

One last comment about maintenance. Do you have a maintenance kit with your pipes? You need one with tape, drone stoppers, hemp (waxed and un-waxed), Teflon tape, small scissors, etc. When you are confident in your instrument’s maintenance, you are ready to warm up and tune up. Stay ‘tuned’ for part 3.


Happy piping.

Tuesday, May 27, 2014

Memorial Day Semi-Annual Back-to-Basics … Part 1

It’s time for my semi-annual back to basics rant. Piping is a year round activity for most of us. We love to play most anytime and anywhere. We love to try new tunes and play old ones. Yet unless we stay true to our training, our musicality may slip. At a recent event, a Memorial Day performance, the band gathered at a Bay Area cemetery to play. We arrived, chatted, put on uniforms, warmed up our instruments, then took far too long to tune and hence we did not give enough time to gather with the drummers and run through a set of music. There were note errors, missed starts, missed pickups and cut-offs. Overall the performance was a ‘B’, but not the ‘A’ we should be performing at. There are many factors affecting a performance. By Memorial Day, every piper worth his, or her, salt should be hitting their stride, a plateau of performance, if you will. And if we’re not, then you need to attend my Semi-Annual Back-to-Basics blog!

The Highland Bagpipes are one of the most physically challenging of instruments to play. To play well a piper must be practiced confidently on his or her chanter (for the tune), have strong lungs and strong lips (to play steady and controlled), a strong arm (to play steadily and well) and a well-tuned instrument. When one of these (chanter, lungs, lips, arm & instrument) is off, the others will (not may) suffer.

A piper needs a strong lips, strong arm and a lot of breath to keep the pipes going. Practicing daily for twenty to thirty (or more) minutes helps develop the strength and stamina a piper needs to play well. You can tell a lot about a piper’s practice time by how long their lips last until he starts to sputter and loose air through his lips. The more you practice on both practice chanter and pipes to the point of sputter, then recover rest, the stronger you will become. Add strong breath support and a strong arm, both gained through practice, and you can then maintain strong and steady pressure keeping the tune, both chanter and drones, playing with an even sound.

Truth be told, it is just what my parents told me when I decided to take up alto saxophone in elementary school: practice and you improve; skip practice and you don’t, your decision son. My parents are very wise. Did I heed their advice through high school: sadly no. I practiced sporadically, or increased practice close to a performance. I was never a star player. Years later, I found out that you don’t just try bagpiping. The bagpipes are a strong taskmaster if you want to improve. Play your chanter every day. If you are new to piping, play your practice chanter until your lips sputter, then return later that day for another session. Soon you’ll be practicing for 30 or more minutes. With strong lips then practice can concentrate on the music. When you are on the pipes (be sure to take time to tune), do the same thing. Your lips, lungs and arm will strengthen allowing you to, once again, concentrate on the music.

Happy piping.

Saturday, May 3, 2014

On the Piper of Tobruk, PM Rob Roy

PM Robert 'Rob' Roy
In June of last year I wrote about a Scots piping hero Bill Millin — who led troops during the D-Day landings in 1944. Many, if not all, have heard of his bravery in piping the troops ashore at Normandy. Yet three years earlier, at the Siege of Tobruk, April - November 1941, in Libya, North Africa, another soldier achieved similar hero status piping for the troops. His name was Robert "Rob" Roy.  

A Scotsman in the 2nd Battalion Black Watch, piper Rob Roy gained the title of Piper of Tobruk for his role in the breakout at Tobruk after being besieged by Axis forces led by Lieutenant General Erwin Rommel during the 241 days. The Port of Tobruk was a key location for the Allies as it was the only major port between Tripoli and Alexandria. Holding it forced the Germans to transport needed supplies over the 1500 km of desert. The location of the port also posed a threat to that same German supply line. The battle was fierce with repetitive bombings and ground assaults. Tobruk marked the first time that the advance of the German Panzers (under Rommel) had been brought to a halt.

As the Allies started their offensive to break out of the Axis stranglehold, Roy was called to play his pipes. Felled by a bullet at the start of the breakout, he got to his feet and continued playing, only to be hit again. Once more he got to his feet, but was hit a third time. Unable to get up this time, he kept playing his pipes while lying on the ground. Pipe Major Roy continued a distinguished military career serving in India and Burma, Gibraltar and Scotland as RSM.

PM Roy passed away on August 24, 1960 while rehearsing for the Edinburgh Military Tattoo. After his death, a military funeral took place at Hayfield Cemetery in Kirkcaldy, when his pipes that had inspired men on the battlefield were heard again — in lament. Five senior army officers who had commanded Pipe Major Roy were among those who joined his widow Hilda at the graveside.

It has been 53 years since PM Roy’s death, and yet his daughters Alice and Margaret, and son Robert are still amazed when they hear of history buffs remembering Roy and his service to his country. As Alice and Margaret recalled last year, "As young children we grew up with the sound of pipes being played by students in every spare room in our Dundee home. Their sound still evokes a curious mix of emotions — they cheer you up one minute, yet make you feel a little sad and homesick at the same time. The drone of the pipes, wailing a slow lament, turns your mind to all those who gave their lives for their country. “

As long as men are stirred to fight for liberty and freedom, men like PM Rob Roy will be stirred to serve and fight. As Roy’s daughter said so eloquently of the soldiers who gave their last breath for their country, “They may be gone, but none will be forgotten."



Saturday, March 15, 2014

Piping for St. Patrick's Day 2014

The Irish came up with a great PR idea in having a day to honor St Patrick. The parades with all manner of participant, bagpipe bands, the green beer, corned beef and cabbage, Irish step dancers, accordion music, Irish flags and parties honoring St Pat galore. Who would have thought that the celebration today is honoring the day a 5th century Christian died, March 17. Patrick desired most of all to reach the pagans of Ireland with the Bible and the truth of Jesus’ love, making disciples of all men.

Patrick was a 5th-century Roman-British Christian missionary and bishop to Ireland. Patrick is probably the best known of Christian missionaries of the island country. History records that at the age of 16, Patrick was taken from his home in Great Britain to live as a slave in Ireland, where he lived for six years before escaping and returning to his family. After becoming a cleric studying in France, he returned to northern and western Ireland. In later life, he served as an ordained bishop, but little is known about the places where he worked. He reached out to the people of Ireland using examples from Irish heritage to explain the Gospel: the shamrock to show the triune God, etc.

The Stewart Tartan Pipes and Drums celebrated along with the best ‘em by marching in the San Francisco St. Patrick’s Day Parade. We had most of our pipers, drummers, color guard and banner carriers out in full regalia, marching in full uniform with full plaid and ostrich feathered bonnets. We were honored with Maribeth Allen joining us for her last gig on bass drum. Playing our standard parade sets, we honored all things Irish with ‘Wearing of the Green’ and ‘Minstrel Boy’ standards along with three other parade sets. We also had Scottish Dancers to march and dance with us. In front of the reviewing stand the band provided ‘extra’ pageantry by marching into formation to play ‘Orange and Blue’ for the dancers. Suffice it to say (and modestly I might add) our band took first place in the parade!

After the parade most of the band hung out together playing at a couple of pubs near the Civic Center. We all enjoyed the playing, as did the patrons, but there wasn’t enough space for us to hang out and have a cold one. Outside our second pub, a mom asked if we might play for her son who loves bagpipe music. Not missing a beat, I started to play, some drummers joined in and I went down on one knee to play for the lad at his eye level. Maybe a third of the band headed out to find a pub and the group I was with headed back to where the cars were parked and ended up being welcomed at The Chieftain Irish Pub, playing everything in our repertoire, plus some. The owner welcomed us like long lost friends, offering food and drink as we played for the appreciative crowd. We hope to return next year, but with even more music. As mentioned earlier, our band had split, so when some of us were leaving, the rest of the band showed up and played for another hour for the revelers. A good time was had by all. Happy St. Patrick’s Day!

Friday, February 14, 2014

On bagpiping tryouts

When playing the bagpipes there is a certain self-imposed pressure in performing well. OK, we do play a very loud instrument and one that ‘speaks’ to many listeners. Yet nothing, for me, holds more pressure than playing for fellow bagpipers in tryouts for a competition band.

Our band has decided that this year, the pipe major, pipe sergeant and pipe corporal will review all pipers who wish to be part of (dare I say the word: tryout for) the competition band. It’s a fascinating idea that challenges each of us. The idea that we must meet a level of playing, meet the criteria of performance, be judged worthy to or not to join the group gives us all pause. And yet, I applaud the idea of setting high standards for play; expecting better performances from each member of our team.

Our band has an overarching principle of inclusion of all who play the highland bagpipes (or drums). If you want to learn the pipes (or drums) we’ll teach you. The only requirement is a dedication to learning, and then performing together at some level. Our band promotes a family environment where we support one another, and demonstrate that with experience pipers coming along side less experience; dedicated pipers encouraging more casual pipers, in an air of caring and support. As musicians you can see that there are several strata of players.

As a Western United State Pipe Band Association (WUSPBA, pronounced: woos-puh-buh said quickly) grade 5 band and nonprofit organization we are all here to learn, continually improve and share our music through performance. The levels of playing ability are observably three tiers and are all marked by a love of our instrument. The top tier is the talented, experienced pipers whose dedication and by their performance and playing abilities leads us. The second tier (here is where I live) is the players who are dedicated, play well in public performance, but continually work to improve (just like tier one) our playing by practicing a lot, etc. In some respects our group has a lot of fun, loves performing and are the heart of the band. The third tier is also part of the heart of the band. They are less fanatical than either tier one or two, but still with a love of the instrument and love playing and performing. Together we make up the band.

This brings me back to tryouts. We are to make an mp3 recording of our quick march medley (QMM) and submit it for review to the pipe major. Challenge …accepted. Making the mp3 is the first hurdle to overcome. Just listen to your family video singing ‘Happy Birthday’ and smile. Now consciously record yourself singing ‘Happy Birthday’ and think about sending it to America’s Got Talent. Each gets a different level of self-scrutiny as you make it. So it is in my preparing to submit a recording of my playing for review.

I remind myself that I am not defined by comparing myself to others, nor am I defined by the outcome of the tryout. To be part of the competition band is an honor. If my fellow players, or I, make the team, excellent! If others (or I) don’t, I’ll be cheering for my mates in the competition band, and it’s back to practice. Which if I think of it (practice) should happen anyway, no matter the outcome. Happy piping!